Cosey does not play on this tune, and Gaumont is the only guitarist audible until
the splice at 10:52.
The raw materials from which the issued version of "He Loved Him Madly" was assembled
have appeared in a couple different forms. Most of the short fragments listed above
(items 8-33) are included on a So What CDR Session of He Loved Him Madly,
although they are differently indexed. With a few exceptions (items 8-12), these
fragments are excerpted from the five takes that were performed in the studio (items
1-7). Several of the fragments include overdubs and/or post-processing of other
kinds. In addition, there are different versions of the multi-take recording: and
early version without echo added, in which take 5 runs out at about 6:27, and a
later version with echo, where a 14:54 take 5 has been assembled from the earlier
takes 5a and 5b.
According to the liner notes to the On the Corner Sessions box (Columbia
Legacy CK7 06239), the issued version "was assembled from five different takes," i.e. items
1-7. But careful listening to the issued version reveals many splices and crossfades,
e.g. at 2:39, 5:14 (2:39-5:14 repeats 0:04-2:39); 6:20, 7:42, 10:47, 10:52, 12:43,
15:45, 20:08, 21:30 (21:30-21:33 repeats 21:27-21:30), 22:35 (22:36-25:01 repeats
20:09-22:35 but without the repeated bit at 21:30-21:33), 30:59, and 31:28 -- many
more than are needed to assemble five takes into a single extended performance.
So it seems that the fragments are an intermediate stage in the editing process.
Maybe the five takes were recorded, then edited and processed, and then those fragments
were re-assembled into the version of the tune released on LP. In any case, here
is how the fragments appear to have been assembled for the version released on
Get Up With It (left), and where the various fragments come from (right):
|
Issued version
|
Fragments
|
|
00:00-02:40
|
Fragment 9 (0:00-2:39)
|
|
02:40-05:15
|
Fragment 9 (0:00-2:36)
|
|
05:15-06:21
|
Fragment 10 (3:04-4:10)
|
|
06:21-07:40
|
Fragment 11 (0:05-1:21)
|
|
07:40-10:47
|
Fragment 6 (0:40-3:47)
|
|
10:47-10:53
|
Fragment 11 (0:05-0:11)
|
|
10:53-12:44
|
Fragment 14 (0:00-1:50)
|
|
12:44-15:45
|
Fragment 15 (0:29-3:30)
|
|
15:45-17:21
|
Fragment 16 (0:15-1:50)
|
|
17:21-20:09
|
Fragment 17 (0:04-2:54)
|
|
20:09-21:13
|
Fragment 20 (2:52-3:56)
|
|
21:13-22:36
|
Fragment 21 (0:18-1:38)
|
|
22:36-23:41
|
Fragment 20 (2:52-3:56)
|
|
23:41-26:02
|
Fragment 21 (0:18-2:39)
|
|
26:02-26:11
|
Fragment 22 (0:08-0:17)
|
|
26:11-26:21
|
Fragment 24 (0:05-0:29)
|
|
26:21-30:13
|
Fragment 25 (0:09-4:01)
|
|
30:13-31:22
|
Fragment 25 (4:43-5:29)
|
|
31:22-32:14
|
Fragment 26 (0:00-0:46)
|
|
Fragment
|
Taken from
|
|
Fragment 6 (3:53)
|
take 1 (1:02-4:54)
|
|
Fragment 7 (0:18)
|
take 2 (0:04-0:14)
|
|
Fragment 8 (2:42)
|
take 2 (0:04-2:45)
|
|
Fragment 9 (3:11)
|
take 2 (0:04-3:14)
|
|
Fragment 10 (4:38)
|
take 2 (0:04-4:42)
|
|
Fragment 11 (1:54)
|
take 3a (0:04-1:57)
|
|
Fragment 12 (0:21)
|
take 3a (2:19-2:37)
|
|
Fragment 13 (0:57)
|
take 3a (2:19-3:16)
|
|
Fragment 14 (2:39)
|
take 3b (0:00-2:37)
|
|
Fragment 15 (4:42)
|
take 3b (1:22-6:02)
|
|
Fragment 16 (1:54)
|
take 4 (0:03-1:52)
|
|
Fragment 17 (4:44)
|
take 4 (1:45-6:27)
|
|
Fragment 18 (4:15)
|
take 5a (1:15-5:25)
|
|
Fragment 19 (1:21)
|
take 5a (5:12-6:22)
|
|
Fragment 20 (3:55)
|
take 5b (0:55-4:48)
|
|
Fragment 21 (2:48)
|
take 5b (4:26-7:12)
|
|
Fragment 22 (0:29)
|
take 5b (6:57-7:25)
|
|
Fragment 23 (0:13)
|
take 5b (7:10-7:22)
|
|
Fragment 24 (0:50)
|
take 5b (7:09-7:58)
|
|
Fragment 25 (5:29)
|
take 5b (8:07-13:34)
|
|
Fragment 26 (0:46)
|
take 5b (13:18-14:03)
|
Some of the fragments (e.g. 6, 10-13, 18, and 20) are preceded by studio chatter,
tuning, or brief rehearsals.
Bill Laswell's Panthalassa (Columbia CK 67909, Sony SRCS 8457) includes
a 13:36 remix of some of this material. There is a different mix of essentially
the same material on
Random Factors: A Collection of Bill Laswell Productions and Collaborations
(Sonic Arcana SACD 1004).
Davis was in bad shape when the Octet returned from the South American tour. He
had missed at least one concert because of a drug overdose. Liebman was also interested
in leaving, having recorded his second ECM album, Drum Ode, just before
the tour. Davis eventually hired Sonny Fortune, and the Octet resumed touring --
e.g. Paul's Mall, Boston (July 28-August 3), Avery Fisher Hall, New York (September
13) -- but Davis' health precluded a busy touring schedule.
|